Tax Refunds in Chapter 7
In Chapter 7, a tax refund is property of the bankruptcy estate. This means the trustee can take it and distribute it to your creditors -- unless you can claim it as exempt.
Timing Matters
The key question is: what portion of the refund was earned before your bankruptcy filing date?
- Pre-petition portion: If you file bankruptcy in June, roughly half of the year's tax refund (the portion attributable to January through June) is property of the estate.
- Post-petition portion: The portion attributable to months after filing belongs to you and is not property of the estate.
In practice, most Chapter 7 trustees look at the full refund for the tax year in which you filed, and some also look at the refund for the year before filing if it has not yet been received.
Protecting Your Refund with Exemptions
You can protect your tax refund by claiming it as exempt on your bankruptcy schedules. The available exemptions depend on your state:
- Federal wildcard exemption: If your state allows federal exemptions, 11 U.S.C. Section 522(d)(5) provides a wildcard exemption that can be used for any property, including tax refunds. The amount varies and can be significant if you are not using it for other property.
- State exemptions: Some states have specific exemptions for tax refunds. Others allow you to use a general personal property or wildcard exemption.
- EITC and child tax credits: These have strong arguments for exemption (see below).
Tax Refunds in Chapter 13
Chapter 13 treatment of tax refunds varies dramatically by district. There is no single national rule. Instead, each trustee and each district has developed its own approach.
Common Approaches
- Full turnover: Some trustees require you to turn over 100% of your tax refund each year. The refund is distributed to creditors through the plan.
- Partial turnover with threshold: Some districts allow you to keep refunds up to a certain amount (for example, $2,000 or $2,500) and turn over the excess.
- No turnover required: Some districts do not require any refund turnover, treating the refund as part of the debtor's budget already accounted for in the plan.
- Plan-specific: Some plans specifically address tax refunds. Your confirmed plan may say exactly what happens to your refund.
Check your plan and local rules: Before spending your tax refund during Chapter 13, verify what your plan says and whether your trustee has a standing order about refunds. Spending a refund you were supposed to turn over can result in a motion to dismiss.
Earned Income Credit and Child Tax Credit
The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and Child Tax Credit (CTC) have special status in many courts. These credits are not a "refund" of over-withheld taxes -- they are government benefits for low-income working families.
Arguments for Exemption
- Public assistance benefit: Under federal exemptions (11 U.S.C. Section 522(d)(10)(A)), public assistance benefits are exempt. Several courts have held that the EITC qualifies as a public assistance benefit.
- Earned wages: The EITC is based on earned income and can be characterized as a wage supplement, making it potentially exempt under wage exemptions.
- Policy considerations: Congress designed the EITC to encourage work and support low-income families. Taking it in bankruptcy defeats that purpose.
Trend: Most courts that have addressed the issue protect EITC from bankruptcy trustees. However, the law is not uniform. If you rely on the EITC, discuss this with your attorney and be prepared to argue the exemption if the trustee objects.
Strategies for Protecting Your Refund
- Adjust your withholding: File a new W-4 with your employer to reduce your withholding. This increases your take-home pay and reduces your refund. Less refund means less for the trustee to take. But be careful not to under-withhold and owe taxes.
- Time your filing: In Chapter 7, filing later in the year means a smaller pre-petition portion of the refund is estate property. Filing in December means almost the entire refund was earned pre-petition; filing in January means very little was.
- Use exemptions strategically: If you have unused wildcard or personal property exemptions, allocate them to your tax refund on Schedule C.
- Receive and spend the refund before filing: If you receive your refund before filing Chapter 7, you can spend it on necessary expenses (rent, utilities, food, car repairs). Spending it on luxury items or to pay favored creditors can create problems.
- Separate EITC from refund: If part of your refund is EITC and part is overwithholding, document the breakdown. The EITC portion may be exempt even if the overwithholding portion is not.
Do not hide your refund. Failing to disclose a tax refund on your bankruptcy schedules is fraud. The trustee will find out -- they have access to your tax returns and can verify refund amounts with the IRS. Always disclose the refund and claim the appropriate exemption.
What Your Plan Says
In Chapter 13, your confirmed plan is a binding order. If the plan says you must turn over tax refunds, you must comply. If it is silent on refunds, check the trustee's standing orders and local rules.
Key plan provisions to look for:
- Any clause requiring turnover of tax refunds
- Whether a specific dollar amount is excluded from turnover
- Whether the plan specifically addresses EITC or other credits
- Deadlines for providing copies of tax returns to the trustee
If your plan is unclear, ask your attorney. If you are pro se, contact the trustee's office directly for guidance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Chapter 13 trustee take my tax refund?
It depends on your district, your trustee's requirements, and what your confirmed plan says. Many trustees require turnover of all or part of the refund. Some districts have standing orders with specific thresholds. Others do not require turnover at all. Always check your plan and your trustee's requirements before spending your refund.
Can I protect my earned income credit in bankruptcy?
The EITC has strong arguments for exemption. Under federal exemptions, it can be characterized as a public assistance benefit (exempt under 11 U.S.C. Section 522(d)(10)(A)). Many courts protect EITC from trustees. However, the law varies by jurisdiction. Document the EITC portion of your refund separately and be prepared to argue the exemption.
How do I keep my tax refund in Chapter 7?
Claim the refund as exempt on your Schedule C using available state or federal exemptions. You can also reduce future refunds by adjusting your W-4 withholding, time your filing strategically, or receive and spend the refund on necessary expenses before filing.
Should I adjust my withholding before filing bankruptcy?
Adjusting your withholding to reduce your refund is generally acceptable. The goal is to match your withholding to your actual tax liability so you do not have a large refund for the trustee to take. Do not reduce withholding so much that you owe taxes -- that creates a new problem.
Related Resources
Filing Tax Returns During Chapter 13 -- the annual filing requirement
What Is Chapter 7? -- overview of Chapter 7 bankruptcy
Chapter 13 Plans -- how repayment plans work
IRS Payment Plan vs. Bankruptcy -- comparing your options
Check Your Bankruptcy Discharge Eligibility
Use the free screener at 1328f.com to check whether federal timing bars affect your ability to receive a bankruptcy discharge.